Sell Stop (HMIN), New Buy (PWRD)

Volatility remains high and this rally hasn't gotten any easier. Trading is very tough. My recent 'success,' if I can call it that, is a result of a commitment to my rules - they are what's kept me in the game. What's encouraging is that the rules appear to work even in very challenging circumstances. There are numerous times over the past couple of months that I would've been shaken out of a position if I was actively managing my holdings - instead I've held on, and time will tell if I profit from this.

Friday the market opened hard and (HMIN) took out my break even stop loss order. This position was opened from a conventional canslim buy point well above the moving averages, and those have had trouble in this rally. Since I'd been up 10% the stop loss was at break even so that's fine with me.

My record since my 'reset' is now 0 - 1 - 2.

(EJ) has been really tough to watch. It's been up as much as 25% and come all the way back to within a few percent of my stop loss order. Turns out the company spun off a unit into an IPO of (CRIC) on Friday. That may have marked a bottom for EJ and it came off the 50 dma Friday morning and is up over 10% now from that point.

Friday I took the capital from the sale of (HMIN) and put it into (PWRD) which I've been looking to get into. It's been trading around the 50 dma for about a week. It remains to be seen if the stock is consolidating or if it will bounce off this area. I purchased close enough to the 50 dma that I was able to put my stop loss at 2% so I have very little capital at risk in this position. So far this morning it's up nicely on solid volume.

Backtesting the New Idea

Here's my very quick study of the top stocks on my watchlist, trying to apply a simple and mostly mechanical purchasing method using the 10 wk ma. I attempted to be very conservative and didn't really throw too much logic in - for the most part I just looked at the charts and bought within 3% of the 10 wk - there are however some noted exceptions that I found to be no-brainers (like STEC on crash day, obviously would not have purchased that one).

Leaders from around 8/21
Rules - Buy limit 3% above 10 wk ma
Sell Stop 5%, breakeven after 10% advance
1 week hiatus after stock stops out
EJ - could've been purchased around $18.60 on 8/25 and survived 5% stop loss (now breakeven) - current price $23.58
HMIN - could've been purchased around $28.75 on 10/2 and survived 5% stop loss (now breakeven) - current price $33.30
PWRD - could've been purchased around $36.69 on 9/2 and survived 5% stop loss (now breakeven), high of $50.49, current price $43.82
FUQI - could've been purchased around $24.35 on 9/2 and would've stopped out same day for 5% loss
FUQI - could've been purchased around $27.44 on 9/18 and would've stopped out for breakeven on 10/1
FUQI - could've been purchased around $28.20 on 10/8 and still holding with 5% stop loss - current price $28.00
STEC - did not come near the 10 week until it gapped down and crashed through - easily avoided
GMCR - was below 50 dma and to be avoided at this time, basing
BIDU - could've been purchased around $337.21 on 8/27 and stopped out on 9/1 for 5% loss
ARST - broke the 50 dma several times and therefore would be avoided
MED - could've been purchased around $18.27 on 10/2 and survived 5% stop loss (now breakeven) - current price $22.38
VIT - 5% loss, then avoided (too wide and loose)

Scorecard:
4 - 3 - 1

4 winners up 26%, 15%, 19%, and 22% - each stock has been up at least 20% at their high since purchase
1 stock still held down less than a percent
3 stocks stopped out for 5% loss
1 stock sold for breakeven

Adaptation

We've been having some interesting discussions on the Trade to Retire forums and I wrote a post there that I'd like to put here on my blog as well as it highlights my thoughts and approach to this currently rally.

Here's how I handle market analysis - it's one thing to have an opinion about the market (it's gone too far too fast, etc.) but it's another to act (trade or not trade) on that opinion. I try to separate the two. If the market is in an uptrend and I see a stock I like in a position I like then I will buy it - whether or not I think a rally is extended. This probably adds to my risk, but I'm just not good at picking market tops, so it's best for me to let the market posture and/or my three strikes rule handle that for me.

Now on the other hand, I do think it's important to adapt to the current environment. Standard CAN SLIM buy points have not worked for weeks. They just haven't. The stocks have closed below the buy point, shaken out holders, then turned and advanced. They advance 10 or 15% from traditional buy points and pull back to a moving average instead of the 20% one could historically count on. I saw this through the middle of the year (it was a very expensive lesson) and since I've adjusted my buying strategy I've managed to survive for a few weeks. I would NOT attempt any buys on breakouts/new highs at this time UNLESS the 50 dma/10 wk line were within about 8% of the buy point - that would allow me my standard stop order while giving me the cushion for the stock to pull back to support ((HMIN) did this).

Better yet, I'm looking to buy around the 10 wk line if I like a stock. I think (PWRD) is setting up perfectly for this, and I will look to purchase this if it dips under $42 (assuming nothing else changes). This position would allow for a tighter stop around 4 or 5% and let the stock work up the moving average or just stop out if it can't hold that area. This is how I bought (EJ) and it allowed me to ride out a lot of volatility.

I've decided to conduct the following exercise. I will go back to August 21st on my watchlist and pick my favorite five stocks, then look at the charts from that day and see what would've happened if I'd picked them up around the 10 wk line (within a percent or two - I bet most or all of them touched off this line since August 21st) with about a 5% stop loss order. I'll bet about 75% of these trades would've yielded a 20% gain, possibly before the stock even made a new high. Furthermore, I'll be I could still own the stock today and be in good shape - in fact I do still own (EJ) from that type of purchase around that time.

Short version is this - I think in the current market, traditional CAN SLIM thinking has had me buying when I should be selling (around the new highs) and selling when I should be buying (stopping out around the moving averages). I don't think it's ALWAYS going to be like this and I firmly believe in CAN SLIM, but I also believe in reviewing past trades and adapting as necessary.

Stay the Course

I'm not posting to this blog much these days, and that's a pretty good thing.

In late August I drew a line in the sand and started over sticking to my rules. Since then I've gone 0-1-1, and I currently hold two positions. That's not tremendous results on the surface, but looking at it relatively shows some improvement.

Simply comparing my results over the last two months to the rest of the year shows progress. I've held one stock, (EJ) since 8/24, which embarrassingly is probably some kind of a record for me - my positions usually don't last that long! The stock is up close to 20% for me at this time, and is breaking out of a second stage cup with handle pattern today which allows me the opportunity to hold it for 20% more gain.

My other stock, (HMIN), is also beginning to work a bit.

What's really encouraging is that I've held these stocks through an extremely turbulent market. I've done so not through some great insight or market wisdom, but just from following my own rules. So far, these have worked. Buying close to the right time and giving these stocks the full 8% stop loss has kept me in the market through some violent shakeouts. Now, of course this could all turn tomorrow but for now it appears to be working.

Most importantly, I've had next to no stress about the market. I enjoying talking about it on the forums associated with this blog, but I don't have any emotional baggage directing my actions with regard to my positions. I buy them and I leave them alone. Sure, I have some fear that I'll fail again - but not nearly like I have in the past, and I'm quite certain I don't act on this feeling.

So I guess all this can be summed up as 'no news is good news.'